St Thomas vs St John: Choosing the Perfect Island
Table of Contents
Are you dreaming of escaping to a tropical paradise with crystal-clear waters, white sandy beaches, and lush greenery? Let’s talk about the U.S. Virgin Islands – St. Thomas and St. John to be exact.
Both islands possess breathtaking landscapes and warm hospitality but they are unique in their own way.
Choosing between the two can be tough, with each island offering a different experience altogether.
In this article, we will take an in-depth look at both islands and help you figure out which one suits your vacation needs the best!
Whether you’re looking for adventure, relaxation, or just a change of scenery; stick around as we dive into the rich culture and beauty that these islands have to offer.
What’s the Difference Between St Thomas & St John?
When it comes to choosing between St Thomas and St John, you might feel like picking based on a coin flip.
Fear not! This section provides you with details on what makes these islands distinct and attractive.
What Type of Traveler Would Like St Thomas?
St Thomas is ideal if you enjoy vibrant, bustling atmospheres. This island offers fantastic shopping opportunities, with loads of unique souvenirs and duty-free goodies. From jewelry stores to fashion boutiques, it’s a shopper’s paradise.
In addition to shopping, St Thomas boasts magnificent views and thrilling activities. If you have a penchant for adventure, you’ll appreciate the water sports, zip-lining, and island excursions.
Foodies will also appreciate the diverse culinary scene; no matter your craving, St Thomas is bound to have a dish that suits your fancy!
What Type of Traveler Would Like St John?
If you prefer a more tranquil and nature-focused experience, St John is the place to be.
Over two-thirds of this island haven is a protected national park. That means beaches are so pristine they’ll take your breath away and rainforests are like something out of a dream.
St John might be your dream destination if you’re a hiker or nature enthusiast. Numerous trails and wildlife encounters await you! Eco-conscious travelers will appreciate the island’s commitment to preserving its natural beauty.
Snorkeling enthusiasts, rejoice! St John is home to an array of stunning underwater sites, so pack your flippers and get ready to explore the vibrant marine life in its crystal-clear waters.
Best Time to Visit
The best time to visit the U.S. Virgin Islands is typically from April to June. During these months, you can expect pleasant weather and minimal rainfall, making it an excellent time to soak up the sun and explore these tropical gems.
December to March is considered the peak season, so it’s when you’ll experience more crowds (and higher prices). But hey, if holiday cheer on a sandy beach is your jam, then go for it!
Now, onto an essential matter: hurricanes. We have to mention this, because Mother Nature loves to keep us on our toes.
While St. Thomas and St. John are stunning throughout the year, it’s important to note that hurricane season runs from June through November.
During this time, especially September and October, tourism slows down due to the potential for bad weather.
Beaches
Are you ready to explore the sandy shores of the US Virgin Islands? Let’s dive into the beautiful beaches of St. Thomas and St. John, where sun-kissed bliss awaits!
Beaches in St. Thomas
St. Thomas is a treasure trove of idyllic beaches, offering a perfect mix of fun and relaxation.
One of its most famous beaches is Magens Bay, where you’ll find an expansive, 1-mile stretch of sand, ideal for basking in the sun.
If you’re all about the coral reefs, then Coki Beach is your go-to place. With crystal-clear waters and a vibrant underwater world, your snorkeling experience will be nothing short of delightful.
And did we mention shopping? Yes, you heard right! Lindquist Beach, besides its jaw-dropping beauty, is only a stone’s throw away from duty-free stores. Shopping, swimming, sunbathing…sounds like paradise, doesn’t it?
Beaches in St. John
St. John is famous for its pristine beaches and awe-inspiring marine life. If you’re an avid snorkeler or just adore fascinating sea creatures, this island has got it all.
Trunk Bay, often referred to as the crown jewel of St. John’s beaches, is home to an underwater snorkeling trail. Pro tip: pay attention to those friendly sea turtles!
For a more secluded and intimate beach experience, there’s Maho Bay. Soft white sands, lush greenery, and sea turtles nesting nearby make for an enchanting atmosphere that is irresistibly immersive.
Things to Do
Are you ready for some sun-soaked adventures? The beautiful islands of St. Thomas and St. John in the US Virgin Islands have a lot to offer, and we’re here to help you decide where to go and what to do.
Things to Do in St. Thomas
St. Thomas is the bustling hub among the US Virgin Islands, offering a wide array of activities for the energetic traveler.
Looking for some adrenaline-pumping fun? Zip-line through the lush, tropical forests of St. Thomas – trust us, it’ll leave you grasping for more.
For the history buffs out there, visit the legendary 99 Steps and take a trip back in time, steeped in the island’s colonial past. Once you’ve caught your breath at the top, don’t miss the mesmerizing views of Charlotte Amalie.
Are you an underwater enthusiast? Explore the vibrant marine life by indulging in snorkeling or scuba diving at breathtaking spots like Coki Beach.
Things to Do in St. John
St. John is where nature gracefully takes center stage! More than half of the island is a protected national park, making it the perfect destination for those who cherish peaceful, unspoiled surroundings.
Get ready to put on your walking shoes, because hiking on St. John is an experience like no other.
Explore the stunning trails weaving through lush greenery and ancient ruins, leading you to picture-perfect beaches.
And speaking of beaches, brace yourself for some of the best snorkeling opportunities in the Caribbean at spots like Trunk Bay and Waterlemon Cay.
And if you want to soak in the laid-back island vibes, take a leisurely stroll around Cruz Bay, St. John’s charming main town, where you’ll find quaint shops, vibrant eateries, and friendly locals.
Nightlife
Nightlife in St Thomas
Let’s enter the fabulous world of St Thomas’ nightlife! It’s as if an explosion of glitter and joy occurred all over the island, giving life to excellent bars, clubs, and live music venues.
No wonder travelers adore this sparkling island gem. One of the coolest places to visit is the vibrant Red Hook district, where you’ll find an eclectic mix of pubs and beach bars brimming with entertainment.
You can dance the night away, indulge in mouthwatering cocktails, or simply bask in the Caribbean beats.
While you boogie the night away, don’t forget to savor some local brews and homemade rum concoctions.
This is the island where the fun never goes to bed – you’ll be spinning around in sheer joy like there’s no tomorrow!
Nightlife in St John
If St Thomas is the life of the party, St John is its more laid-back, carefree cousin. The nightlife here leans more towards relaxed and enchanting vibes.
Behold the charm of beachside bars with glowing tiki torches, where you can sip on exotic cocktails under the starry Caribbean night sky.
While the rhythm of St John may be a wee bit slower, it’s perfect for couples or anyone looking for that cozy feel-good atmosphere.
Although you won’t find as many loud clubs and bustling dance floors, the island still promises a delightful and intimate evening.
In St John, you tuck your party shoes away and tune into the soothing sound of the gentle sea waves while basking in good conversation.
Dining & Restaurants
Oh, you lucky foodie adventurer! While both St. Thomas and St. John have a mouthwatering array of dining options, their unique culinary landscapes are vastly different.
Get ready to discover the delectable delights of each island and take your taste buds on a tropical journey.
Eating in St. Thomas
St. Thomas, the bustling epicenter of the US Virgin Islands, brings culinary indulgence to new heights.
It has a diverse array of dining experiences, from cozy local eateries to upscale international cuisine.
You’ll have the opportunity to savor fresh seafood, delicious Caribbean flavors, and inventive vegetarian dishes – all with stunning ocean views.
Picture yourself feasting on lobster by the beach or tearing into a coconut-crusted mahi mahi at a waterfront gem. Now, that’s a flavor-packed adventure, if you ask us.
There are also trendy food trucks, offering unique twists on local favorites for when you’re in a hurry or simply want a lighter bite. From fish tacos to Caribbean barbecue, your hunger will never go unsatisfied.
Eating in St. John
If you’re seeking an immersive island dining experience, St. John delivers in spades.
Known for its undeniable charm, St. John boasts an eclectic selection of casual eateries and neighborhood bistros serving mouthwatering, locally sourced dishes.
Think freshly caught seafood, tropical fruit, and organic produce bursting with color and flavor.
Can you already sense your hunger growing? You’ll have the chance to munch on local delicacies such as conch fritters or dive into a succulent plate of slow-roasted goat at a beachside shack.
St. John also knows how to cater to more sophisticated palates. You can indulge in refined dining experiences at upscale restaurants, sipping on craft cocktails and savoring gourmet dishes infused with Caribbean flavors and international flair.
Where to Stay
But now comes the big question: where to stay on St. Thomas and St. John? Let’s dive into the most popular areas and some recommended hotels and resorts in each island.
Most Popular Areas to Stay in St. Thomas
St. Thomas, the island of endless entertainment and delectable dining options, has several fantastic areas to rest your head after a day of adventure.
Charlotte Amalie: The bustling capital known for its shopping and colorful architecture is a top choice for the traveler who loves to be in the heart of it all.
Red Hook: A hip spot on the eastern side of the island, perfect for those seeking easy access to the ferry to St. John and a vibrant nightlife scene.
Magens Bay: The tropical paradise that’s home to one of the most beautiful beaches on the planet (not exaggerating). Ideal for beach lovers and serenity seekers.
Hotel & Resort Recommendations for St. Thomas
Now that you know where you’d like to be, here are some accommodations we recommend:
- Luxurious: Indulge your senses at The Ritz-Carlton with its stunning views and top-notch services.
- Mid-Range: If you’re looking for an all-inclusive stay, Bolongo Bay Beach Resort offers beachfront rooms, as well as a variety of activities and dining options.
- Budget: Emerald Beach Resort offers fantastic ocean views and access to one of St. Thomas’ best beaches at an affordable price.
Most Popular Areas to Stay in St. John
St. John, on the other hand, caters to the nature enthusiast and beach aficionado in you. Let’s explore the popular areas on this pristine island:
Cruz Bay: The island’s lively main town, with delicious dining options and a perfect starting point for National Park explorations.
Coral Bay: A more remote and tranquil hideaway on the eastern side of the island, ideal for those looking for serenity and nature immersion.
North Shore: Famous for its breathtaking beaches and turquoise waters, the go-to spot for the ultimate Caribbean beach vacation.
Hotel & Resort Recommendations for St. John
With these areas in mind, let’s reveal some fantastic St. John accommodations:
- Luxurious: Immerse yourself in island vibes at The Westin St. John Resort Villas, boasting spacious suites and stunning ocean views.
- Mid-Range: Gallows Point Resort offers spacious suites with stunning views of the Caribbean Sea.
- Budget: For the budget-savvy traveler, the lovely St. John Inn provides comfort, hospitality, and, of course, easy beach access.
Which is Cheaper
Let’s get down to the nitty-gritty. The average daily cost per person in St. Thomas is about $218, while in St. John, it’s a tad lower at $192. Not a huge difference, but every penny counts when you’re living the island life!
As you prance around these tropical paradises, you’ll notice some key distinctions between the two.
St. Thomas is more populated and developed than St. John, which means you’ll find a wider array of accommodation options, from luxury resorts to budget-friendly hotels – an excellent pick for the savvy traveler.
However, don’t dismiss St. John as an expensive choice; it offers a more laid-back and intimate experience for those seeking a serene getaway.
When it comes to activities and entertainment in these delightful havens, St. Thomas tends to be a tad pricier thanks to its broader range of offerings such as shopping, dining, and nightlife.
But fear not, budget-conscious explorers can still indulge in fantastic beaches and watersports in St. John without breaking the bank.
So what’s the verdict? St. John might be the wallet-friendly winner compared to St. Thomas in this case.
No matter where you lay your sun hat, you’re bound to have an extraordinary time in these tropical paradises.
Final Thoughts
Now that you’ve learned the ins and outs of St. Thomas vs St. John, it’s time to make a decision.
Will you opt for the bustling vibe of St. Thomas, or will you surrender to the serene shores of St. John?
The choice is yours, but whichever island you choose, one thing is certain: adventure awaits!
But before you go, don’t forget to check out our other article on St Thomas vs St Croix – it’s packed with even more insights and tips to help you plan the holiday of a lifetime.
We hope that our blog post has helped guide you towards making an informed decision about which tropical paradise to call home for your next vacation. Happy travels!
