9 Spots for the Best Pizza in Maui
Who doesn’t love a good pizza? Whether you’re looking for a classic cheese pizza or something more inventive, you won’t have to look far to find the perfect slice in Maui.
From island-style pies to wood-fired classics, there are plenty of delicious pizza parlors throughout the island.
To help you find the best of the best, we’ve compiled a list of the top 9 spots for pizza in Maui that will satisfy any craving.
1. Flatbread Company
If you’re looking for the best pizza on Maui, Flatbread Company should be at the top of your list.
Their dough is made with 100% organic ingredients and fired up in traditional clay ovens.
For the full island experience, try their Mopsy’s Kalua Pork: Kiawe smoked pork shoulder, mango BBQ sauce (made in-house), organic red onions, Maui pineapple, Hawaiian goat cheeses and more.
All that flavor goodness?! Let’s just say you’ll have an extra slice if no one’s watching!
Address: 89 Hana Hwy, Paia, HI 96779, United States
2. Serpico’s
For an East Coast pizza meal without having to jump on a plane, look no further than Serpico’s in Upcountry Maui.
Now here’s the real deal: we’re talking hand tossed Jersey-style thin crust pizza here! Watch them toss it right before your eyes, then bake it until the cheese gets a golden-brown tan.
This authentic Italian eatery doesn’t just stop at pizza; they also offer some scrumptious entrees ranging from Shrimp Scampi to Fettucine Alfredo.
Address: 7 Aewa Pl, Makawao, HI 96768, United States
3. Fabiani’s
Get your Italian grub fix at Fabiani’s, a popular place for locals and vacationers alike.
The menu is full of delicious options, like the Lorenzo: fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, prosciutto & arugula – with an added drizzle of truffle oil for good measure.
It’s no wonder why this is one of the restaurant’s favorites!
Step away from the mediocre pizza places and check out Fabiani’s for some real Italian goodness.
Address: 95 E Lipoa St, Kihei, HI 96753, United States
4. Sale Pepe
One of the best restaurants on Front Street, the legendary artisan pasta and pizzas at Sale Pepe will transform your taste buds into a flavor whirlwind.
One of their specialties is homemade lasagna with local ingredients that will take any diet off track!
And just when you thought it couldn’t get any better, their pizza comes around, topping all other competitors with its deliciousness.
Don’t believe us? Believe the locals – go treat yourself at this family-owned spot and you can thank us later.
Address: 878 Front St #7,8, Lahaina, HI 96761, United States
5. Pizza Madness
Aptly named Pizza Madness, this local joint has been serving up mouth-watering pies for years.
The secret to their success? A secret pizza dough recipe that’s been lovingly handed down through the generations like an ancient family heirloom.
Plus, they offer more than just pizza – try their tender buffalo wings or meatballs for a delightful surprise!
Perfect for large gatherings or family outings, your wallet won’t take a hit at this local pizzeria.
Address: 1455 S Kihei Rd Unit # 103, Kihei, HI 96753, United States
6. Lahaina Pizza Company
Located in the heart of Maui’s vibrant Front Street is Lahaina Pizza Company.
Not only will you get the best pizza around, but you can also treat yourself to unbeatable ocean views from their lanai.
The menu is casual and plentiful with some of the most creative pies that can be tailored to your every whim — have it as mild or wild as you like!
For something special, try The Works: homemade meatballs, pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives and sweet onions.
Address: 730 Front St, Lahaina, HI 96761, United States
7. Outrigger Pizza
Outrigger Pizza Company featured on “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives” is Maui’s hidden gem.
Tucked away in the parking lot of Kukui Mall is this tiny yellow trailer, outfitted with the island’s first mobile woodfire pizza oven.
Service is speedy too; you can chow down on a slice of heaven in under 10 minutes; start to finish!
Warning: you won’t be able to resist just one slice of their signature Three Cheese Pizza – it’s THAT good.
And if you want something that screams ‘Maui’ try the Kalua Pork Pizza. It comes loaded with pork, garlic aioli, kale, onion, and a three-cheese blend – all finished off with a lilikoi drizzle.
One of the best cheap eats in Maui, you simply cannot pass up on this place!
Address: 1819 S Kihei Rd, Kihei, HI 96753, United States
8. Prison Street Pizza
Prison Street Pizza serves up some of the best Jersey-style pizza you’ll ever have – and with over 40 years of pizza practice, you can bet that it’s simply delish.
For lovers of meaty concoctions, try their Carnivore pizza, which is practically overflowing with bacon, ham, sausage and pepperoni – yum!
Whether you’re sharing between friends or treating yourself for an indulgent night in, Prison Street Pizza will be sure to please even the pickiest palates.
Address: 133 Prison St, Lahaina, HI 96761, United States
9. Pizza Paradiso
If you’re looking for great pizza with a twist, Pizza Paradiso is where it’s at. Offering a unique menu created with local ingredients, your pizza will be made with flair and freshness that can’t be beaten.
Try the Godfather: juicy chicken, mushrooms, artichoke hearts and sundried tomatoes — it’s sure to hit the spot!
And if you like to choose all the ingredients yourself , never fear – build your own delicious combination and get creative.
Address: 3350 Lower Honoapiilani Rd Ste 208, Lahaina, HI 96761, United States
