10 Places That Serve the Best Grilled Cheese in NYC

Who doesn’t love buttery goodness? If you’ve been dreaming of the ultimate grilled cheese sandwich, look no further: NYC is here to save the day.

From classic cheddar to exotic fillings, these ten places will be sure to make your taste buds rejoice.

With so much deliciousness to explore, there’s no doubt that this journey into grilled cheese nirvana will be one you won’t soon forget!

1. Ed’s Lobster Bar

Ed’s Lobster Bar is New York City’s best spot for Lobster Grilled Cheese. Hidden away in a cozy corner, this bar welcomes visitors with friendly staff and a full bar of wines, beers and more.

The ultimate combination of savory seafood and melted deliciousness, their Classic Lobster Grilled Cheese is to die for.

If you’re feeling extra hungry, you can add bacon for a few extra bucks.

But that’s not all! You can also munch on lobster rolls and savor the freshness of their raw bar.

Address: 155 Grand St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Lobster Grilled Cheese by Eds Lobster Bar NYC
Lobster Grilled Cheese Photo by Ed's Lobster Bar NYC

2. Saxelby Cheesemongers

The hunt for the best grilled cheese in NYC has come to an end at Saxelby Cheesemongers.

Located in the little basement of Chelsea Market, this cheesy gem is a must-try for all sandwich enthusiasts.

Nowhere else will you encounter such crispy toast paired with an impressive layer of cheese that will leave your mouth watering for more.

All menu items are delicious and they have daily specials, but you can’t go wrong with The Chelsea; Alpha Tolman, Marcona Almond, Fig and Chili Relish.

Saxelby prides itself on crafting some of the planet’s most deliciously gooey grilled cheese sandwiches – take their word for it and go give it a try!

Address: 75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

3. Murray’s Mac & Cheese

When you’re looking for the best grilled cheese in NYC, there’s one sandwich that stands out among all the rest: the Murray’s Melt, a classic grilled cheese wedged between sourdough.

It’s one of those dishes that has perfected simplicity to new heights. The bread is thick and lightly charred, giving it a delightful crunch with a side of greasy goodness.

And then there’s the cheese, sure enough, it’ll have you pulled apart each slice like stringy nirvana.

The secret to this melty masterpiece? We’ll never know – but we do know that hands down it truly is the best grilled cheese in all of New York City.

Address: 254 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States

8 Best Anime Stores in NYC: Ultimate Guide

4. RH Rooftop Restaurant

Situated centrally in the Meatpacking District, the RH Restaurant offers all the perks of a glamorous rooftop restaurant with stunning views and chandeliers to boot.

But none of that elegance stops them from crafting the perfect grilled cheese sandwich.

The Truffled Grilled Cheese on Artisan Sourdough sandwich is like none other – savory, cheesy goodness wrapped up in two slices of toasted sourdough bread.

Visit this posh restaurant and indulge in oozing bites of deliciousness. You won’t regret it!

Address: 9 9th Ave, New York, NY 10014, United States

Donut Grilled Cheese by Clinton Hall New York
Donut Grilled Cheese Photo by Clinton Hall New York

5. Clinton Hall

The best way to experience NYC cuisine? Grilled Cheese! And the perfect spot to satisfy this cheesy craving is at Clinton Hall.

This hip and trendy hangout offers an extensive array of craft beer and gastropub fare, but their mastermind creation must be the ultimate game changer – the Doughnut Grilled Cheese.

Presenting a fresh glazed donut as its decadent outer layer and stuffed with gooey mozzarella cheese, it’s also paired with a bowl of tomato soup.

In other words, prepare yourself for a party in your mouth!

Address: Multiple locations, check website to confirm.

6. Melt Shop

Any sandwich lover worth their salt knows that the only way to a heart is through the stomach.

So if you really want to impress, don’t bother with cheesy pickup lines – head straight to Melt Shop instead!

Topping the charts for serving the best fast food in New York, their classic grilled cheese featuring American and NY cheddar on crispy bread will heat up your taste buds better than the hottest summer romance.

Crackles of crunch, creamy gooey flavors – it’s the perfect match.

Address: Multiple locations, check website to confirm.

7. Cheese Grille

Cheese Grille is the place to go for the best grilled cheeses in NYC! In their graffiti interior, they are dishing up cheese dreams on wooden cutting boards.

For a classic cheesy experience, nothing beats their 3 Cheese blend: cheddar, asiago and gruyere on Levain Pullman bread.

First bite and you’re hit with a wave of freshly-buttered goodness, followed by a glorious cheese pull that’s, dare we say, the real deal.

Address: 188 Allen St, New York, NY 10002, United States

8. Sadelle’s

Sadelle’s is that place you have to try if you’re in the mood for some tasty grub.

Perched in the heart of Soho, it has a vintage-style vibe complete with buzzy chatter, high ceilings and plenty of seating options – including an outdoor area.

If you’re feeling bold, have a cocktail and order the classic grilled cheese. Trust us – it won’t disappoint!

Address: 463 W Broadway, New York, NY 10012, United States

28 Things to Do in New York for First Timers

Best Grilled Cheese in Brooklyn

9. The Bedford

Nothing will make you feel more like a Williamsburg hipster than tucking into one of Bedford’s famous Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup sandwiches!

This classic dish has been given a gourmet twist, with NY State cheddar, oregano and sriracha gracing slices of sourdough.

And it’s served in the perfect setting too; this rustic-chic gastropub occupies the site of an old garage, so you really can dine on the edge of trendiness.

Address: 110 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States

10. Dépanneur

Dépanneur is a rustic shop that has all of your artisanal food and house needs covered, plus they serve up some serious coffee and sandwiches that are hard to pass up.

Think sharp white cheddar, juicy tomato, and fresh arugula pressed to perfection on buttered sourdough for the Classic Grilled Cheese experience.

Or kick things up a notch with their Hangover Cure, that’s the classic with a twist – it includes creamy avocado, an egg, and a good dose of sriracha.

Leave the Chef Boyardee untouched; this is grilled cheese done right.

Address: 242 Wythe Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States