Jamaica vs Puerto Rico: Which Vacation is Better?

Table of Contents

Looking for a tropical paradise to escape the daily grind? Jamaica and Puerto Rico are two sizzling vacation spots that will get you feeling the warmth of the sun and the rhythm of the Caribbean beat.

But, which one is the right fit for you? That’s the battle of the beaches, folks! We’re talking rum drinks, reggae tunes and swaying palm trees.

So, let’s break it down and find out which of these tropical gems will have you feeling more chill than ever before.

Trust us, you won’t want to miss out on this Jamaica vs Puerto Rico showdown!

Is Jamaica or Puerto Rico Better?

Looking for a vacation spot where you can splash around like a dolphin or waltz through rich history? Well, let’s take a gander at Jamaica and Puerto Rico.

If you’re seeking high-energy activities like jet skiing, snorkeling or plunging off waterfalls, Jamaica is undoubtedly the king of the hill.

But if cultural immersion is more your jam, Puerto Rico offers a platter of historical sites and delicious local cuisine to satisfy your curious cravings.

What is Jamaica Known For?

If you thought Jamaica was just a beach-bum haven, think again! This stunning island is a whole lot more than powdery sands and crystal-clear waters.

From exploring jungle waterfalls to sipping on some of the world’s best coffee, Jamaica is a real trove of treasures.

Take the family out for a day of adventure and explore the coffee plantations, or indulge in a little romance at one of the many resorts – complete with extra perks to sweeten the deal.

San Juan Puerto Rico
San Juan Puerto Rico

What is Puerto Rico Known For?

With its Spanish colonial past and mixed culture, Puerto Rico is a hub of history and diversity.

But if there’s one thing this island is famous for, it’s the rum. With approximately 80% of the rum consumed in the US coming from Puerto Rico, you could say they’ve got the art of rum-making down to a T!


Beaches in Jamaica

Jamaica’s beaches are the stuff of dreams. The combination of white sand and blue ocean is so stunning that Hollywood couldn’t resist featuring some of them in their movies.

What’s even more remarkable is that each beach has its unique vibe and purpose.

Seven Mile Beach is perfect for those seeking out entertainment, while Frenchman’s Cove offers a serene escape with a no-music policy.

If you’re after some waves, scoop up your surfboard and head to Winifred Beach or Long Bay.

Finally, for those who want to explore the underwater world, Montego Bay Marine Park and Pellew Island are hotspots where you can swim with turtles, stingrays, and even lionfish!

Beach in Ocho Rios Jamaica
Beach in Ocho Rios Jamaica

Beaches in Puerto Rico

With crystal-clear waters and powdery white sand, Puerto Rico is the perfect place to catch some rays and sip on some coconuts.

One beach that definitely stands out is Flamenco Beach, where you can bask in the warm sun and enjoy some of the clearest waters in the Caribbean.

But Puerto Rico isn’t just about white sands and calm seas. Playa Negra, for example, is a beach that may be off the beaten path, but it’s well worth the trek.

This hidden gem is surrounded by lush greenery and has black sand that contrasts beautifully with the clear blue waters.

It’s the perfect spot for a romantic picnic or a peaceful day of reading your favorite book.

For those who are thrill-seekers, head over to Crash Boat Beach, where you can try your hand at snorkeling or even cliff jumping!

And if you’re a surfer, then Rincon Beach is the place to be, with its world-renowned waves and laid-back atmosphere.

5 Best Breathless Resorts for Your Next Getaway

Things to Do

Things to Do in Jamaica

Jamaica may just be the ultimate destination for outdoor enthusiasts, offering a little bit of everything from mountain peaks to ocean depths.

The Blue Mountains, standing tall at over 7,000 feet, not only hosts coffee bean farms but also a chance to hike amongst tropical waterfalls and rivers.

For the more adventurous water babies, the 180-foot-long Blue Lagoon is a must-visit, or snorkeling or scuba diving at multiple diving sites gives you a chance to truly appreciate the underwater beauty.

And for the truly brave, Stingray City beckons just offshore Montego Bay.

But it’s not just sunbathing and sipping coconut water that makes a Jamaican vacation worth it.

Take a tour of Fort Charles and learn about its English roots, or explore the Museums of History and Ethnography – where you can even learn about a sunken underwater city!

And let’s not forget, the Bob Marley experience, where you can immerse yourself in reggae and get your groove on.

Castillo San Felipe del Morro San Juan United States
Castillo San Felipe del Morro San Juan

Things to Do in Puerto Rico

Move over Jamaica, Puerto Rico is equally awesome when it comes to outdoor activities!

El Yunque National Forest is a nature lover’s paradise, offering a diverse range of mountainous terrain, stunning waterfalls, and hundreds of animal and plant species to explore.

Castillo San Felipe del Morro, also known as El Morro, is one of the most significant attractions in Puerto Rico’s history, built in the 16th century as a defense system.

With its remarkable location on a rocky promontory overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, it was considered the most unconquerable Spanish fortification of its time.

The bioluminescent bay in Mosquito Bay provides an extra glow to the night sky, making it well worth the journey for a canoe or kayak tour.

If that’s not enough, make sure to spend some time exploring the Cavernas del Río Camuy.

This natural attraction is part of one of the largest cave networks in the world and is just an hour and 20 minutes drive from San Juan.


Nightlife in Jamaica

You know what they say, “No worries, mon”, and that’s exactly the vibe you’ll find in Jamaica’s nightlife scene.

Whether you’re sipping on some deliciously smooth rum or busting a move on the dance floor, everything is relaxed and carefree.

This chill atmosphere also encourages mingling between locals and travelers alike.

Montego Bay and Negril are the main party hotspots, offering everything from beachside cocktails to all-night reggae jams.

Hawaii vs Puerto Rico: Which Destination is Better?

Nightlife in Puerto Rico

This tropical island is a night owl’s dream, with endless options for dancing, drinking, and having a good time.

This island knows how to party, and the nightlife options are as diverse as they are countless.

Whether you’re in the mood for a glamorous night out at a hotel nightclub or a gritty dance party at a roadside chinchorro, there’s something for everyone.

And let’s not forget the beach bars, where you can sip tropical cocktails while your feet sink into the sand.

11 Top-Rated Singles Resorts in Jamaica if You're Ready to Mingle

Where to Stay in Jamaica

Looking for a place to stay in Jamaica? Lucky for you, the island’s got a plethora of options that’ll suit anyone’s pocketbook.

The most popular areas to stay in Jamaica include Montego Bay and Ocho Rios.

You can get direct beach access for every budget, from the bargain backpacker to the big-bucks luxury seeker.

You don’t necessarily have to go into credit card debt territory to find a decent place to rest your head.

3-star hotels with basic amenities can be had for around $130 a night, while resorts with swim-up suites usually run between $300-$500.

Of course, if you’re feeling flush, you can always spring for the ultra-luxe package, which starts at a cool grand.

Just be prepared to cough up even more dough if you’re planning your Jamaican jaunt during peak season.

Our top hotel picks for Jamaica:
Excellence Oyster Bay
Hyatt Zilara Rose Hall
Riu Montego Bay

Where to Stay in Puerto Rico

You’re in for a treat because Puerto Rico has some of the most amazing accommodations you’ll ever see.

From cozy beachfront bungalows to luxurious villas nestled in the mountains, you’ll find everything you need to make your stay unforgettable.

If you’re looking for a more laid-back vibe, head to the west coast where you’ll find some of the best surf spots and laid-back beach towns.

Or, if you’re in the mood for some serious pampering, check out the resorts in San Juan where you’ll be treated like royalty.

Our top hotel picks for Puerto Rico:
Condado Vanderbilt Hotel
San Juan Marriott Resort & Stellaris Casino
The Royal Sonesta San Juan