Tourist Traps Exposed: 18 Overrated NYC Spots to Skip

Ever wondered which spots in New York City might not be worth the long lines and pricey tickets? This article is your secret guide to the most overrated tourist attractions in the Big Apple.

From crowded landmarks to overhyped shops, we’ll explore which popular places could be skipped to make room for even cooler, less-known adventures in the city that never sleeps!

Brooklyn Bridge at night
Brooklyn Bridge at night

1. The Brooklyn Bridge

The Brooklyn Bridge is a beauty, no doubt, but during peak hours, it’s like a human version of bumper cars! If you’re thinking of enjoying a serene stroll across, think again. Between 4 PM and 7 PM, it’s a sea of people.

You might spend the trek staring at the back of someone’s head instead of the stunning NYC skyline. And selfies? Good luck getting a shot without a photobomber—snapping that perfect pic can feel like winning the lottery.

Here’s a tip: visit early in the morning or late at night. You’ll have more space to breathe—and actually be able to see the bridge!

2. The Vessel at Hudson Yards

Ever strolled through Hudson Yards and spotted that shiny structure everyone seems to huddle around? That’s The Vessel, a towering spiral of staircases you can climb for city views.

But hang on, is climbing this honeycomb-like giant really the highlight of your NYC trip? You might find more joy roaming the nearby High Line or grabbing a bite at a local eatery.

READ NEXT
20 Comfort Food Hotspots in NYC for a Cozy Meal

3. Statue of Liberty

The Statue of Liberty, while a symbol of freedom, can be a bit of a letdown. You might find the lines long and the area filled with eager tourists hustling for the best view.

Instead, enjoy a free ride on the Staten Island Ferry, where the breeze is lovely and the sights just as grand. Remember, you can see Lady Liberty in all her glory without setting foot on Liberty Island.

Statue of Liberty over the Scene of New York City
Statue of Liberty over the Scene of New York City

4. Central Park Carriage Rides

Carriage rides through Central Park may seem like a charming way to see the green heart of New York City, but they may not be what you expect. Instead of a private, serene tour, you could find yourself amid bustling traffic, not the peaceful clip-clop you envisioned.

Plus, costs can be steep—it’s not just a few bucks to trot around the park. Some visitors have felt that their rides were overpriced for what they got.

Many people are now questioning the care and treatment of the horses, sparking a debate about the ethics of these rides. Instead, you could enjoy a leisurely walk or a bike rental to explore Central Park at your own pace.

READ NEXT
3-Days in New York: The Best NYC Winter Itinerary

5. Little Italy

In the heart of NYC, Little Italy beckons with its colorful charm. You might hear it’s the go-to for authentic Italian vibes, but locals might hint that it’s more for the tourists now.

Instead of wandering among endless pasta venues that can be pricier than you’d hope, consider a trip to Arthur Avenue in the Bronx. Renowned as the “real” Little Italy, it’s less crowded and offers cozy spots with genuine Italian cooking.

6. Times Square

Times Square is like a giant neon billboard come to life; it’s where the action make you feel like you’re in the heart of the Big Apple. But real talk: it’s often jam-packed with people and the costs can make your wallet wince.

Ever thought $25 for a burger felt a bit steep? And while those costume characters seem fun, watch out for surprise photo fees.

Times Square Subway Station
Times Square Subway Station

7. One World Observatory

Visiting the One World Observatory is like reaching for the sky in the city that never sleeps. Perched atop the Freedom Tower, it promises vistas that stretch for miles. But while your eyes feast on panoramic views, your wallet might not be as thrilled.

Factor in the cost and crowds, and you might feel like you’re on a conveyor belt, shuffled along with a sea of tourists. If you fancy a more down-to-earth experience, where you won’t have to jostle for space, One World could be on your list.

READ NEXT
How to Get Around New York as a Tourist

8. 5th Avenue Shopping

Fancy a stroll down one of the world’s most famous streets? 5th Avenue is a shopper’s slice of heaven, boasting high-end brands left and right. But don’t let the glitz blind you—while the window displays are second to none, the crowds are just as grand.

Not only can it be rough on your wallet, but your patience may wear thin navigating through the sea of fellow shop-goers. Maybe skip the hustle and consider cozy boutiques found off the beaten path for a more serene and equally trendy shopping spree.

9. Wall Street’s Charging Bull

Have you ever seen the big bronze bull on Wall Street? It’s hard to miss! Tourists flock to this shiny beast for photos. They even rub its nose and horns for good luck.

This heavyweight champ tips the scales at 3.5 tons. That’s as much as a small elephant! While it’s a cool piece of art, you won’t get much more than a quick selfie and maybe a funny story.

Empire State Building NYC New York
Empire State Building NYC New York

10. Empire State Building

The Empire State Building is iconic, but when you’re eyeing those lengthy lines and steep prices, it might give you pause. For a cool visit without the fuss, tip your hat to this classic from afar.

You can catch superb views across many other spots in NYC without emptying your wallet!

11. South Street Seaport

In the heart of NYC, South Street Seaport bustles with tourists. It’s often touted as a must-see historic district, but let’s get real: it’s packed! With shops and eateries aiming for that old New York charm, they might just snag your wallet with high prices.

Sure, the cobbled streets are cute, and the view of the Brooklyn Bridge is pretty sweet, but don’t get too swept up. You might find a hidden lighthouse or a memo about the Titanic, yet the magic can fizzle with the swarm of selfie sticks.

READ NEXT
NYC Fall Packing List: 11 Essential Things You’ll Regret Not Bringing

12. The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

If you’re in New York City and curious about MoMA, you’re in for a mix of modern and contemporary art. It’s iconic, right in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, and boasts an impressive array of artworks.

With over 150,000 pieces, including works by Warhol, Matisse, and Van Gogh, your cultural appetite is sure to be satisfied. Despite its fame, some visitors find it crowded and hard to navigate, especially during peak times.

Exhibits might not always meet everyone’s expectations, as not all that glitters is gold. But, with a creative spirit and a love for art, MoMA can be a delightful spot on your New York City adventure.

The High Line New York
The High Line New York

13. The High Line (On Weekends)

Did you know the High Line can be jam-packed on weekends? On Saturdays and Sundays, it’s like everyone in New York had the same idea. You’re shoulder-to-shoulder with crowds, which can really spoil that peaceful vibe you’re looking for.

The secret is to visit mid-week when you can actually enjoy the plant life and artwork without bumping into a dozen people.

14. Chinatown (Canal Street)

Canal Street, the bustling heart of Chinatown, draws you in with its vibrant storefronts and street vendors selling souvenirs. But be careful, it’s easy to get swept up in the crowded sidewalks and end up with trinkets you might not want!

Ditch the overpriced items here and stroll a block or two out for authentic flavors at local eateries. Remember to watch out for those too-good-to-be-true designer knockoffs.

READ NEXT
20 Fun & Romantic Winter Date Ideas in NYC

15. Top of the Rock Observation Deck

Visiting the Top of the Rock Observation Deck gives you stellar views of New York City from the heart of Manhattan. However, with tickets required and space at the peak often crowded, some locals argue it may not merit the hype.

On your visit, you’ll zip up 70 floors and find yourself peering out across the city. The views are panoramic, with terraces facing every direction. Before you make the climb, consider how much time you have, as queues can be long and tickets must be booked in advance.

Top of the rock observation deck
Top of the rock observation deck

16. Madame Tussauds Wax Museum

Madame Tussauds in New York might make you feel like you’re rubbing elbows with celebrities. But let’s get real, these stars are made of wax! Found in the busy Times Square, this museum is one in a chain of 21.

You might be dazzled for a moment, but remember, there’s a whole city out there with unique attractions.

17. M&M’s World

Visiting M&M’s World in New York City might seem like a sweet adventure, but it’s often buzzing with more people than unique flavors. This colorful store is packed wall-to-wall with merchandise that celebrates the iconic candy brand.

You’ll find a dizzying array of M&M’s in every shade imaginable, and while it could be neat to pick out a mix that matches your living room, remember that the candy tastes the same whether it’s blue, yellow, or green.

READ NEXT
20 Comfort Food Hotspots in NYC for a Cozy Meal

18. The “Friends” Apartment Building

Have you strolled by the iconic Friends’ apartment building in Greenwich Village? Many fans do, hoping for a peek into the ’90s sitcom lifestyle. But here’s the scoop: the inside scenes of Monica and Rachel’s place were not shot there, it was all TV magic!

While it’s fun to see the outside, remember, it’s just a building and the real show happened on a set miles away. Snap a quick pic if you must, but don’t be surprised if it feels just like any other NYC corner.

Final Thoughts

So now you know, some spots in NYC might just leave you feeling a bit let down, with your wallet lighter and your feet more tired than they need to be.

But don’t worry, if you’re curious about what to do on your first visit to New York, we’ve got you covered. Check out our article on must-see places and secret corners where the real magic of New York shines!