15 Best Restaurants in Greenport, Long Island

Offering some of the best restaurants around, Greenport is a foodie’s paradise.

Quality and variety await you, with everything from seafood to Italian and farm-to-table specialties at your fingertips.

Whether you’re looking for an intimate dinner or a fun night of small plates with friends, we’ve got you covered.

Get ready for a gastronomic adventure as we take you through Greenport’s best restaurants for your culinary pleasure!

1. Claudio’s Waterfront

Claudio’s Waterfront is Greenport’s hometown favorite, bringing together locals and visitors alike with their seafood offerings.

On the weekends, they kick things up even more with live music to accompany dinner or drinks – a perfect combination for a warm summer night.

For those looking to eat and drink, their menu serves something for everyone: you can find seafood platters, Lobster Mac & Cheese, and Baha Shrimp Tacos – even the little ones will love it with an extensive kid’s menu!

Address: 111 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

Claudios Waterfront Greenport NY
Photo by Claudios Waterfront Greenport NY

2. Lucharitos

Lucharitos is the spot to go for a sizzling taco and a tasty margarita – it’s the brightest, most fun Mexican eatery in Greenport!

Step into an eclectic world of bright-colored decor and artwork, as you sample their chef-inspired Tex-Mex dishes with a touch of vintage luchador twist.

Treat yourself to their Grilled Shrimp Taco or Seasonal Fish Taco with a delicious seasonal fruit marg. Mexican food never looked so good!

Address: 119 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

3. Billy’s by the Bay

Billy’s by the Bay is the ultimate seafood hotspot. A chill spot right by the docks and an impressive terrace, not to mention their tiki bar!

Whether you’re in the mood for a classic steamed lobster or something more adventurous, like their delicious stuffed shrimp with scampi sauce – you’ll definitely find something that hits the spot.

And if you’re feeling extra hungry, they have a lobster roll that will surely satisfy your cravings.

Address: 2530 Manhanset Ave, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

14 Best Brunch Spots on Long Island to Start Your Day

4. Noah’s

At Noah’s, the farm-to-table menu takes center stage. Sourced from some of the best farms and foragers in the local area, chef Noah Schwartz is a master at transforming ingredients into amazing dishes.

Menu items include dishes like steamed mussels in rich romesco broth and halibut poached to perfection in coconut milk.

And let’s not forget the top-notch wine selection which elevates any already delicious meal.

All of this together gives it that extra special finesse that makes this place stand out!

Address: 136 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

5. Brix & Rye

If your idea of a great night out requires sipping on top-notch drinks, munching some killer pizza, and kicking it with friends in a low-key but upbeat atmosphere, then Brix & Rye is just the place.

It’s mastered the balance between relaxed and vibrant, private and warm – you get the experience of an upscale bar, but in a chill setting.

There’s plenty to choose from: signature cocktails & craft beer, or if you’re feeling adventurous try the pizza with mushrooms, truffle oil and ricotta – so cheesy yet oh so good.

The food and drinks here prove that style can be effortless!

Address: 308A Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

6. 1943 Pizza Bar

If you’re looking for a casual spot to grab some delicious Italian bites, head on over to 1943 Pizza Bar.

Their most popular pizza is the Red Pie – made with mozzarella, ricotta and their famous Nonna’s Meatballs, cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven.

Want something extra special? Not a problem – they also offer over 20 toppings for you to custom make your own!

Plus, their laid back atmosphere is the perfect place for enjoying their pizzas with some local wine or beer.

Address: 308 D, Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

7. The Frisky Oyster

At The Frisky Oyster, you’ll find a chic bistro offering innovative American cuisine with a hip vibe.

Daily culinary offerings showcase the best of local ingredients; every meal is an adventure like no other.

We recommend trying the seared sea scallops on roasted butternut risotto and the grilled atlantic halibut on coconut sticky rice and thai green curry broth.

Address: 27 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

8. The Halyard

Nestled at the Soundview Hotel in Greenpoint, The Halyard in Greenport is a paradise for foodies.

This eatery will make you feel like you’re traveling through the local land with its delectable menu of flavors and textures.

Treat yourself to the Confit of Montauk Monkfish, served with white beans, asparagus, and radish – a combination fit for any king.

Other must-try dishes include the Grilled Rack of Lamb served with warm grain salad, snap peas and black garlic – sure to excite even the most discerning palate.

Reservations are required to eat here so make sure you book ahead of time!

Address: 58775 County Rd 48, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

14 Best Brunch Spots on Long Island to Start Your Day

9. Ellen’s on Front

If you want to check out one of the best restaurants in town, Ellen’s on Front is definitely a great pick.

From the beautiful interior with its tall ceilings and intricate abstract painting on one wall, to their extensive menu featuring a signature duck fried rice and delicious red-miso marinated beef short ribs, you won’t be disappointed.

Plus, if you’re a wine enthusiast like us, they also feature some amazing wines from local North Fork vineyards.

Address: 38 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

10. First and South

First and South is the perfect spot with a cozy atmosphere to enjoy some delicious seasonal New American fare.

Whether you’re a fan of fried chicken sandwiches or ahi tuna burgers, First and South has it all.

If you’re looking for something special, try their famous paella – it’s an absolutely delightful concoction of flavors prepared with finesse by their talented kitchen staff.

And don’t forget to feast your eyes on the captivating artful chalkboard murals created by artist Kara Hoblin!

Paired with delicious food and excellent drinks, First and South is the perfect spot to wine, dine, and feel fine.

Address: 100 South St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

11. Pearl Restaurant & Bar

Looking for some grub in Greenport? Look no further than Pearl Restaurant, a hidden gem located on the beautiful North Fork of Long Island.

Not only you can enjoy the finest Asian cuisine and seafood, but you won’t be compromising on your juicy American bar food favorites either!

The menu is chock-full of amazing dishes fit for any palate; from Korean BBQ pork belly and filet mignon to glazed ribs and Korean Fried Chicken wings, every dish is cooked to perfection.

Forget about feeding your belly with disappointment; with second to none service and atmosphere that puts a smile on everyone’s face, there’s no better place in town to get your grub on.

Address: 409 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

12. Porto Bello

Are you looking for the perfect spot to kick your feet up and relax? Look no further than Porto Bello.

Their outdoor patio overlooks the marina and is just begging to be enjoyed.

Not only is it a great spot to take in some stunning views and sip on delicious cocktails, it’s also the perfect place to indulge in fine Italian cuisine.

Their menu features local seafood, like Linguine & White Clam Sauce, as well as land-based specialties – Pomegranate Duck Confit anyone?

Whether you’re planning a quiet evening out or hosting a larger gathering, Porto Bello offers the perfect combination of waterfront scenery, delicious eats and top-notch drinks. Live la dolce vita!

Address: 1410 Manhanset Ave, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

15 Best Spas on Long Island for a Blissful Escape

13. Olive Branch Restaurant & Bar

The Olive Branch Restaurant & Bar will make you feel right at home. Cozy up in the dining room, or take your meal to their patio and enjoy sweeping views of the harbor.

Not only is their ambiance comforting, but their food is too! From Turkey to France, Greece to Italy, they serve up classic Mediterranean dishes that are sure to hit the spot.

Whether it’s a melt-in-your-mouth Lamb Shish Kebab or a Baked Hummus with a hint of something special, your taste buds will thank you for visiting Olive Branch.

And don’t forget about their signature Grilled Octopus and Branzino – it’ll be love at first bite!

Address: 120 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

14. Alpina

Alpina is the ideal place to let loose, have some good food, and enjoy the pleasant atmosphere.

Located in Greenport Village, it’s an unexplored gem that offers a fun but sophisticated vibe.

Treat your tastebuds by trying their delicious Swiss-inspired brunch served during Saturdays and Sundays.

Select from a variety of dishes like omelettes with wild mushrooms, emmentaler and swiss chard, to duck hash served with yummy jus and poached egg. Take your pick and expand your dining horizons!

Address: 45 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States

15. Casa Amigos Restaurante

Ready to let the good times roll? Then head on down to Casa Amigos Restaurante.

This great upscale eatery, situated on Front Street in Greenport is sure to tempt you with a delicious array of Mexican-American food.

One of the menu highlights is their Pollo Poblano with Mole Sauce — simply divine!

Or, if seafood is more your style, try their lip-smacking Shrimp Al Chipotle or Fish Tacos.

Address: 110 Front St, Greenport, NY 11944, United States